Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
Side Dinner Salad
Toasted Ravioli
Chicken Tenders
Bruschetta
About
Michael T's Italian-American Specialties
Welcome to Michael T's Italian-American Specialties, a gem nestled in the heart of New Hartford, NY. Located at 8390 Seneca Tpke, this family-owned eatery has become a cherished staple for locals and travelers seeking authentic Italian-American cuisine. With a warm and inviting atmosphere complemented by friendly service, Michael T's is the perfect spot for casual dining, family gatherings, or a cozy dinner date.
As you step into Michael T's, you'll be greeted by the enticing aromas of homemade Italian recipes that have been perfected over the years. The menu is a delightful blend of seafood and traditional Italian dishes, offering items like the Seafood Visalli, which features sautéed shrimp and scallops tossed with broccoli and roasted red peppers in a light scampi sauce over thin spaghetti—a true seafood lover's delight priced at just $28. For fans of classic comfort foods, the Homemade Lasagna, layered with pasta, rich tomato sauce, and mozzarella, is a must-try at only $19.
The restaurant's dedication to quality and authenticity is evident in every bite. Diners rave about the Chicken Riggies, a signature dish featuring bite-sized chicken pieces and peppers in a delightful sauce that has garnered much acclaim. Other beloved starters like Risotto Bites and Fried Calamari set the stage for a great meal, ensuring there's something for everyone on the menu.
The customer reviews speak volumes about the dining experience at Michael T's. One guest described their visit as the "best time I've had in a long time," praising the incredible seafood offerings paired with attentive service. Another patron highlighted the cozy ambiance, perfect for enjoying delectable dishes like the tender Pork Osso Buco or the melt-in-your-mouth Haddock Au Gratin. With reasonable pricing that won't break the bank, it's easy to see why Michael T's has garnered a loyal following.
Whether you're a long-time fan or a first-time visitor, Michael T's Italian-American Specialties delivers a sense of home with every meal. Each dish is crafted with care, ensuring that every visit is a memorable one. Don't forget to make reservations, as this cherished spot fills up fast—especially for those who want to immerse themselves in a true Italian dining experience!
Book a table
Make A Reservation
“ Best time I've had in a long time. Server was terrific! I ordered the fish fry and it was some of the best seafood I've had. And I'm the type that gets it directly from a seafood market! Outstanding job to entire staff. Will definitely highly recommend to all my friends and family! ”
“ We are big fans of this local, family owned eatery, that's been a staple of Seneca Turnpike in New Hartford for years. The atmosphere is casual and the staff is friendly (our bus girl Alex was particularly pleasant!). They offer generous portions of Italian/American cuisine, including local favorites like chicken riggies and greens trunfio. The prices are reasonable and they can accommodate large groups for dinner or a special event . Reservations are recommended. ”
“ Cozy and casual, with a nice bar to go sit and have cocktails at. We had Pork Osso Buco that was out of this world! The meat was so tender and fell right off the bones. Our server was so polite and attentive. The prices are reasonable as well. ”
“ Love the chicken supreme!! Nice, family like, comfortable and not too much waiting. Always good service but, the last time we went the table and seats had crumbs all over them and the tables were not washed good. 12- 2023 ”
“ I haven't been here in 10 years, and I just so Happened to Pull in today, and it is just phenomenal, Ive had Haddock from Just About every Restaurant, Ive been too, and this is 100% the Best. We Orded the Chicken Ann Marie , Haddock Au Gratin , Risotto Bites and the Bruschetta. And Every is Amazing, the Risotto Bites and the Bruschetta, was Some of the best Appetizers I have Every Had. The Haddock was Just Great, you didn't even Have to Chew, it just Melts in your mouth. And the Chicken was also Great, Very Tender and Flavorful. Atmosphere and Service was also very Good. Price is Normal nothing to Crazy. For the Atmosphere, it is definitely a Sit Down Type of restaurant. All in all, if your Looking for a GREAT Italian Restaurant this is the Place to go. ”
“ We were just driving to Texas Road House, seen this place and turned around. We ate all the food before taking a picture. This dinner you can taste scallops as scallops, haddock as haddock, and shrimp as shrimp. They've done very well, not over cooked or well done. You just need to show up and savor the flavor. Top 10 on my list of places to eat ; ) ”
“ Michael T’s did a great job catering for SLU football team today! The food was so good! Thank you! ”
“ Lot's of Delicious food, very far price . ”